Over the years, the Bottle Hill Tavern’s location has varied and has been known as the Waverly House, the Madison House, and the Bottle Hill Tavern. Over the past 25 years, The Mullins family ran “Poor Herbies” from 1992 until 2017 until its closure and purchase last December when four long-time Madison residents purchased the establishment and renamed it the Bottle Hill Tavern, celebrating the great history of Madison, NJ.

The new owners and their families (Horn, Haralampoudis, Flemming, and Horsey) are committed to honoring the success of the Mullins Family for the past 25 years, as well as the great history of our tavern through the celebration of great food and drinks, great experiences and most of all ...great neighbors!